Hello dear
Welcome to Primo Pizza - Ponte Vedra Beach
Primo Pizza - Ponte Vedra Beach offers an authentic New York-style pizza experience right in Florida. Located at 10870 US-1 #114, this beloved eatery is known for its deliciously crafted pizzas, including their famed Sicilian-style Grandma pie and the unique Inside Out option. Salad lovers can enjoy fresh offerings like the Caprese and Antipasto, while dessert options feature tempting cannoli. Customers praise the outstanding service and welcoming atmosphere, making it a true community gem. With rave reviews highlighting low-grease pizzas and generous portions, Primo Pizza promises not just great food, but a warm dining experience that feels like home.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
MOZZARELLA STICKS
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA W/ SPAGHETTI
SAUSAGE, PEPPERS & ONIONS
PHILLY CHEESE STEAK
About
Primo Pizza - Ponte Vedra Beach
If you find yourself in Ponte Vedra Beach, you owe it to your taste buds to experience Primo Pizza. Nestled at 10870 US-1 #114, this charming eatery has quickly become a local favorite, captivating pizza lovers with its quintessential flavors reminiscent of New York City. A call to +1 904-217-0203 is your first step toward an incredible culinary journey.
Primo Pizza prides itself on crafting pizzas that bring a slice of New York to North Florida. The menu features an impressive array of options, from classic cheese pies to inventive strombolis that let you customize with your choice of toppings. For just $10.99, the pepperoni & mozzarella stromboli is a crowd-pleaser, while the meat lovers version packs a flavorful punch at $13.99. Each bite is a reminder of why pizza is such a beloved dish—the perfect crust, melty cheese, and fresh ingredients all dance together in perfect harmony.
The reviews speak volumes about the experience at Primo Pizza. Customers rave about the low grease levels, making it an ideal meal that stays enjoyable even when reheated the next day. One patron, Zach Ahmed, noted how reminiscent the cheese and sauce were of authentic New York flavors, declaring it an 8.5 out of 10—high praise for any pizza establishment. Linda Dohert echoed this sentiment, highlighting not only the incredible pizzas but also the warm, inviting atmosphere brought forth by the welcoming owners.
If you're dining with children, don't miss the kid-friendly offerings like the kids pizza and chicken fingers, each priced reasonably under $10. For just $2.99, wash it all down with a refreshing soft drink and embrace the delightful family atmosphere.
Beyond pizza, Primo Pizza offers an enticing range of Italian dishes. Reviews consistently laud the homemade dressings and flavorful salads, making it a well-rounded choice for anyone who appreciates traditional Italian cuisine. As Erica Puccio expressed, it’s not just the pizza; the entire experience invites a sense of home and familiarity.
All in all, Primo Pizza - Ponte Vedra Beach is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, high-quality Italian dishes in a friendly and welcoming environment. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make this spot your next foodie destination.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Im about to rate Primo Pizza by Nocatee. Ponte Vedra St Aug. I had a taste last week and it had me questipn who the #1 was here in N. FL. I can smell the New York from here old guy on phone sounds like a guy from howard beach. #yankee #pizza Orderd cheese pie well done. Was there as it came out of oven. Ate it leas than 5 min. 8.5! Cooked perfect, slightly well. Only way to order it. Cheese sauce ingredients here bring me back to nyc. Thank you ”
“ What a great place! The pizza is amazing and the owner of the place is a genuinely kind person. My debit card wouldn’t work and he offered to just give me the food when I stepped outside to deal with the bank. I will be getting all of my pizza here from now on. Thank you!! ”
“ Best pizza I have had in all my travels! The perfect fold and best blend of ingredients in every bite. As a New Yorker I was so happy to find such an amazing place not just for pizza but great salad, and homemade dressings, and other entrees like their eggplant! I absolutely recommend you make Primos your place for incredible Italian food, and a sense of home & family! ”
“ 1st time visitor, five stars, extremely low grease, we loved it, even the leftover piece was good the next day and did not get soggy. Looks like we’ll be coming back for more pizza in the future. ”
“ Had an amazing meal at Primo Pizza! My two pizzas and garlic knots were out-of-this-world delicious, and the prices couldn’t be better. The owners were so warm and welcoming, making our dine-in experience truly special. Can’t wait to come back! ”
“ If you’re looking for quality real NY pizza, this is your place. This is tasty NY style pizza. The sauce and cheese dough and crust were absolute perfection. One thing I wish pizza places would offer is a spicy pizza. 2 pieces filled me up and my stomach is never ending as I come up on 6 months pregnant. 2 pieces also filled my husband up, too. He was surprised but happy about it since we were able to feed us and our 2 girls plus bring half a pie home. Really quality pizza and a laid back restaurant with space for families. I thought it was funny my husband wore all his Boston hoodie and patriot hat and we walked into an all loving NY sports covered wall. We bought 2 drinks and a 16 inch pepperoni and got out under 25 plus left overs ”
“ You really need to check them out! Great pizza and great people. I love their chicken parm and pizza. Everything I've ordered has been top knotch. The dough, ingredients, and rolls are definitely high quality! The people are really kind and professional. My order is always done when they say it will be ready for pick up. I'm so glad I go here often. I love this place! ”
“ Excellent experience. They were a little behind, but they managed expectations and were a well-oiled machine. Pushing out orders fast, taking phone orders and communicating. 10/10, I will definitely be back! ”